Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. TESLA! Cathy Wood ARK Funds Bubble BURSTS! - 12th May 21
2.Stock Market Entering Early Summer Correction Trend Forecast - 10th May 21
3.GOLD GDX, HUI Stocks - Will Paradise Turn into a Dystopia? - 11th May 21
4.Crypto Bubble Bursts! Nicehash Suspends Coinbase Withdrawals, Bitcoin, Ethereum Bear Market Begins - 16th May 21
5.Crypto Bubble BURSTS! BTC, ETH, XRP CRASH! NiceHash Seizes Funds on Account Halting ALL Withdrawals! - 19th May 21
6.Cathy Wood Ark Invest Funds Bubble BURSTS! ARKK, ARKG, Tesla Entering Severe Bear Market - 13th May 21
7.Stock Market - Should You Be In Cash Right Now? - 17th May 21
8.Gold to Benefit from Mounting US Debt Pile - 14th May 21
9.Coronavius Covid-19 in Italy in August 2019! - 13th May 21
10.How to Invest in HIGH RISK Tech Stocks for 2021 and Beyond - Part 2 of 2 - 18th May 21
Last 7 days
US Economy and Stock Market Addicted to Deficit Spending - 17th Oct 21
The Gold Price And Inflation - 17th Oct 21
Went Long the Crude Oil? Beware of the Headwinds Ahead… - 17th Oct 21
Watch These Next-gen Cloud Computing Stocks - 17th Oct 21
Overclockers UK Custom Built PC 1 YEAR Use Review Verdict - Does it Still Work? - 16th Oct 21
Altonville Mine Tours Maze at Alton Towers Scarefest 2021 - 16th Oct 21
How to Protect Your Self From a Stock Market CRASH / Bear Market? - 14th Oct 21
The Only way to Crush Inflation (not stocks) - 14th Oct 21
Why "Losses Are the Norm" in the Stock Market - 14th Oct 21
Sub Species Castle Maze at Alton Towers Scarefest 2021 - 14th Oct 21
Which Wallet is Best for Storing NFTs? - 14th Oct 21
Ailing UK Pound Has Global Effects - 14th Oct 21
How to Get 6 Years Life Out of Your Overclocked PC System, Optimum GPU, CPU and MB Performance - 13th Oct 21
The Demand Shock of 2022 - 12th Oct 21
4 Reasons Why NFTs Could Be The Future - 12th Oct 21
Crimex Silver: Murder Most Foul - 12th Oct 21
Bitcoin Rockets In Preparation For Liftoff To $100,000 - 12th Oct 21
INTEL Tech Stock to the MOON! INTC 2000 vs 2021 Market Bubble WARNING - 11th Oct 21
AI Stocks Portfolio Buying and Selling Levels Going Into Market Correction - 11th Oct 21
Stock Market Wall of Worry Meets NFPs - 11th Oct 21
Stock Market Intermediate Correction Continues - 11th Oct 21
China / US Stock Markets Divergence - 10th Oct 21
Can US Save Taiwan From China? Taiwan Strait Naval Battle - PLA vs 7th Fleet War Game Simulation - 10th Oct 21
Gold Price Outlook: The Inflation Chasm Between Europe and the US - 10th Oct 21
US Real Estate ETFs React To Rising Housing Market Mortgage Interest Rates - 10th Oct 21
US China War over Taiwan Simulation 2021, Invasion Forecast - Who Will Win? - 9th Oct 21
When Will the Fed Taper? - 9th Oct 21
Dancing with Ghouls and Ghosts at Alton Towers Scarefest 2021 - 9th Oct 21
Stock Market FOMO Going into Crash Season - 8th Oct 21
Scan Computers - Custom Build PC 6 Months Later, Reliability, Issues, Quality of Tech Support Review - 8th Oct 21
Gold and Silver: Your Financial Main Battle Tanks - 8th Oct 21
How to handle the “Twin Crises” Evergrande and Debt Ceiling Threatening Stocks - 8th Oct 21
Why a Peak in US Home Prices May Be Approaching - 8th Oct 21
Alton Towers Scarefest is BACK! Post Pandemic Frights Begin, What it's Like to Enter Scarefest 2021 - 8th Oct 21
AJ Bell vs II Interactive Investor - Which Platform is Best for Buying US FAANG Stocks UK Investing - 7th Oct 21
Gold: Evergrande Investors' Savior - 7th Oct 21
Here's What Really Sets Interest Rates (Not Central Banks) - 7th Oct 21
CISCO 2020 Dot com Bubble Stock vs 2021 Bubble Tech Stocks Warning Analysis - 6th Oct 21
Precious Metals Complex Searching for a Bottom - 6th Oct 21
FB, AMZN, NFLX, GOOG, AAPL and FANG+ '5 Waves' Speaks Volumes - 6th Oct 21
Budgies Flying Ability 10 Weeks After wings Clipped, Flight Feathers Cut Grow Back - 6th Oct 21
Why Silver Price Could Crash by 20%! - 5th Oct 21
Will China's Crackdown Send Bitcoin's Price Tumbling? - 5th Oct 21
Natural Gas News: Europe Lacks Supply, So It Turns to Asia - 5th Oct 21
Stock Market Correction: One More Spark to Light the Fire? - 5th Oct 21
Fractal Design Meshify S2, Best PC Case Review, Build Quality, Airflow etc. - 5th Oct 21
Chasing Value with Five More Biotech Stocks for the Long-run - 4th Oct 21
Gold’s Century - While stocks dominated headlines, gold quietly performed - 4th Oct 21
NASDAQ Stock Market Head-n-Shoulders Warns Of Market Weakness – Critical Topping Pattern - 4th Oct 21
US Dollar on plan, attended by the Gold/Silver ratio - 4th Oct 21
Aptorum Group - APM - High RIsk Biotech Stocks Buy, Sell, Hold Investing Analysis for the Long-run - 3rd Oct 21
US Close to Hitting the Debt Ceiling: Gold Doesn’t Care - 3rd Oct 21
Powell: Inflation Might Not Be Transitory, After All - 3rd Oct 21
Original Oculus VR HeadSet Rift Dev Kit v1 Before Facebook Bought Oculus - 3rd Oct 21
Microsoft Stock Valuation 2021 vs 2000 Bubble - Buy Sell or Hold Invest Analysis - 1st Oct 21
How to profit off the Acquisition spree in Fintech Stocks - 1st Oct 21
�� Halloween 2021 TESCO Shopping Before the Next Big Panic Buying! �� - 1st Oct 2
The Guide to Building a Design Portfolio Online - 1st Oct 21
BioDelivery Sciences International - BDSI - High RIsk Biotech Stocks Buy, Sell, Hold Investing Analysis for the Long-run - 30th Sep 21
America’s Revolving-Door Politics Behind the Fall of US-Sino Ties - 30th Sep 21
Dovish to Hawkish Fed: Sounds Bearish for Gold - 30th Sep 21
Stock Market Gauntlet to the Fed - 30th Sep 21
Should you include ESG investments in your portfolio? - 30th Sep 21
Takeda - TAK - High RIsk Biotech Stocks Buy, Sell, Hold Investing Analysis for the Long-run - 29th Sep 21
Stock Market Wishing Away Inflation - 29th Sep 21
Why Workers Are NOT Returning to Work as Lockdown's End - Wage Slaves Rebellion - 29th Sep 21
UK Fuel PANIC! Fighting at the Petrol Pumps! As Lemmings Create a New Crisis - 29th Sep 21
Gold Could See Tapering as Soon as November! - 29th Sep 21

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

Wage rates, Immigration and Jobs

Economics / Immigration Aug 07, 2007 - 09:34 AM GMT

By: Gerard_Jackson


On the other hand we have the opposing fallacy that immigrants steal jobs. In fact, back in July 2004 John Stone, former head of the Australian Treasury, accused illegal immigrants of stealing jobs from Australians. So which is it? The first fallacy actually rests on very important economic truth that too many economists ignore: so long as there is sufficient capital and land to employ people and the free market prevails persistent widespread unemployment cannot. What is missing, however, is the price of labour. I have no doubt that if the hourly wage rates for those agricultural jobs that Americans are said to look down their noses at were to jump to $30 there would be an abundance of applicants.

(Although it is true that labour will always find work so long as the means to employ it is available, this does not in itself mean that real wage rates will rise. If the labour supply rises faster than the means of employment, i.e., the supply of capital goods, then real wage rates must fall if full unemployment is to be maintained. A situation of full employment being one where there are always jobs for those who are willing and able to work).

This brings us back to the fallacious view that immigrants are doing jobs that Americans do not want. But this is not the real situation at all. The reason why Americans won't do these jobs is because they get higher wages in alternative lines of work. In other words, low paying jobs are in those areas that cannot compete for sufficient labour. Therefore, what these employers and their supporters are really saying is that they cannot pay market wage rates.

When capital accumulation grows at a faster rate than the workforce real wage rates rise. Reverse the situation and real wage rates will fall. So when the rate of capital accumulation exceeds the growth in the labour force certain labour intensive activities become less profitable because they can no longer compete for labour at the going rate. This means that labour ‘shortages' appear in the low-paid areas of the economy. As every economist and economic commentator is supposed to know, these labour shortages will be particularly felt by marginal producers.

Another — and very important — way of viewing this problem is to see it as an inability of marginal producers to raise labour productivity by an amount that would enable them to pay competitive wage rates. Unable to pay the market rate these producers have tried to resolve their problem by using large-scale immigration to cut real wages by increasing the supply of labour. These employers and their supporters argue that without immigrant workers they will have to abandon their businesses. Two points need to be raised here. The obvious one is that changes in economic conditions are always forcing businesses to close while new ones open. This process is most marked in technology. For example, should canal owners have been protected against railways and railways against the cars?

The less obvious point is that the use of immigrant labour in these circumstances damages the economy by keeping open suboptimal firms. In the absence of cheap labour many of these economic activities would have to cease, meaning that the land and capital they use would be employed in more profitable activities where wages are higher. It will be argued that the products of these activities would have to be imported. This situation would be beneficial for foreign exporters — particularly in poor countries — and American consumers. The former because they now have another market, and the latter because their purchasing power has risen. This reveals another economic fact: as countries become more capital intensive their more labour intensive activities in the tradable area will tend to move to more labour intensive countries. This is why Taiwan's shoe industry is gradually moving overseas.

Putting it in a nutshell, using immigrant labour to expand the supply of labour will exert a downward pressure on real wage rates, starting with the unskilled and semiskilled. However, situations can emerge where capital accumulation has exceeded the size of the workforce to such an extent that increasing the labour supply will actually raise real wages. This is not the case in America or Australia. As an aside, it was suggested to me that highly qualified women with children are able to resume their careers by hiring cheap nannies. This results in a net benefit to the economy. But this is the fallacy of composition. Just because a very well-off families can benefit from cheap labour that does not mean that the families of unskilled workers will also benefit — quite the opposite.

What the masses benefit from is capital accumulation and not open borders. To see how this happens let us take a brief look at the wages of New York maidservants for the years 1914-1922 On the eve of WW I the average weekly wage of a maidservant was $3.50: by 1922 it had risen to about $14 — a 300 per cent increase in money terms — while for the same period the consumer price index rose from 30 to 50, a 66 per cent rise. This means that these girls' real wage rate had more than doubled in real terms 1 . This even was neither isolated nor rare. In 1947 the wages of unorganised US domestic servants were 2.72 times as high as they were in 1939, while the wage of the highly unionised steel workers had risen by on 1.98 times the 1939 level 2 . The reason for the substantial increases was capital formation. In other words: economic growth 3 .

Now what would have happened if those middle class families who could no longer afford to hire domestics had demanded that the government allow a free flow of cheap female labour into the country to drive down real wage rates? They would have been justly ridiculed for their selfishness and economic illiteracy. Yet this is exactly what many businessmen are demanding.

(By the same logic, marginal producers should also demand that those companies who invest in cost-reducing technologies should have their profits taxed away to protect marginal competitors against the threat of financial extinction).

Porous borders will undoubtedly find the unskilled Joe Blows being forced top compete against immigrant labour. Looked at from this angle one could argue that using immigrants to provide cheap nannies for well-off families is a direct form of income transfer from the poor to the better off. Given above facts and basic economics one is left wondering why the open borders mob at the Wall Street Journal are so blasé about the economic and social consequences of allowing millions of illegal immigrants to effectively drive down wage rates. Is the WSJ — a paper that prides itself on its economic sophistication — completely oblivious to the fact that its nostrums for dealing with illegal immigration 4 amount to a policy of using uncontrolled immigration to completely offset the beneficial effects of capital accumulation?

1. (1967=100, Handbook of Labor Statistics, US Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics. Also Benjamin M. Anderson, Economics and the Public Welfare , LibertyPress, 1979 first published 1949. p. 87.

2. There is also Mountifort Longfield's brilliant Lectures on Political Economy , 1834. In this book he shows how capital accumulation raises real wage.

2. The Impact of the Union in F. A. Hayek's A Tiger by the Tail: The Keynesian Legacy of Inflation, The Institute of Economic Affairs , 1978).

4. It always refers to illegal immigrants as being merely “immigrants”, thus allowing it to smear critics as “nativists”.

Gerard Jackson

Gerard Jackson is Brookes economics editor.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in