Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Stock Markets and the History Chart of the End of the World (With Presidential Cycles) - 28th Aug 20
2.Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook... AI Tech Stocks Buying Levels and Valuations Q3 2020 - 31st Aug 20
3.The Inflation Mega-trend is Going Hyper! - 11th Sep 20
4.Is this the End of Capitalism? - 13th Sep 20
5.What's Driving Gold, Silver and What's Next? - 3rd Sep 20
6.QE4EVER! - 9th Sep 20
7.Gold Price Trend Forecast Analysis - Part1 - 7th Sep 20
8.The Fed May “Cause” The Next Stock Market Crash - 3rd Sep 20
9.Bitcoin Price Crash - You Will be Suprised What Happens Next - 7th Sep 20
10.NVIDIA Stock Price Soars on RTX 3000 Cornering the GPU Market for next 2 years! - 3rd Sep 20
Last 7 days
US Presidential Election Forecast Matrix, Stock Market Uncertainty - 29th Oct 20
Stock Market Turning? Look For These Support Levels - 29th Oct 20
Silver: A Conceivable Dead-Cat-Bounce on the Cards - 29th Oct 20
Stocks are Strong but be Aware of this Continuing Pattern - 29th Oct 20
The Most Profitable Way To Play The Gold Boom - 29th Oct 20
Why You Should Hire An Accountant To Complete Your Tax Return - 29th Oct 20
Global Banking: Some Sectors Look as "Precarious as Ever" - 28th Oct 20
Silver Price Minor Dip Possible Before 2nd Major Upleg Starts - 28th Oct 20
�� How to Carve a Simple and Scary Pumpkin Face for Covid Halloween 2020 �� - 28th Oct 20
Gold Price One Last Dip Likely Then Major Upleg to New Highs - 28th Oct 20
Smart Money Is Going All-In On This New Gold Frontier - 28th Oct 20
Gold Stocks Still Correcting - 27th Oct 20
Gold and Crypto: Is This How Charts Look Before A Monetary Collapse? - 27th Oct 20
Silver's Coming Double Trigger Shotgun Price Explosion - 27th Oct 20
The $126 Billion Gold Opportunity in Australia - 27th Oct 20
Tips to Breeze through Your Spanish Classes Online - 27th Oct 20
Try The “Compounding Capital Gains” Strategy Today - 26th Oct 20
UK Coronavirus Broken Test and Trace System, 5 Days for Covid-19 Results! - 26th Oct 20
How the Coronavirus is Exacerbating Global Inequality, Hunger - 26th Oct 20
The Top Gold Stock for 2021 - 26th Oct 20
Corporate Earnings Season: Here's What Stock Investors Need to Know - 25th Oct 20
�� Halloween 2020 TESCO Supermarkes Shoppers Covid Panic Buying! �� - 25th Oct 20
Three Unstoppable Forces Set to Drive Silver Prices - 25th Oct 20
Car Insurance And Insurance Claims and Options - 25th Oct 20
Best Pressure Washer Review - Karcher K7 Full Control Unboxing - 25th Oct 20
Further Gold Price Pressure as the USDX Is About to Rally - 23rd Oct 20
Nasdaq Retests 11,735 Support - 23rd Oct 20
America’s Political and Financial Institutions Are Broken - 23rd Oct 20
Sayonara U.S.A. - 23rd Oct 20
Economic Contractions Overshadow ASEAN-6 Recovery - 23rd Oct 20
Doji Clusters Show Clear Support Ranges for Stock Market S&P500 Index - 23rd Oct 20
Silver Market - 22nd Oct 20
Goldman Sachs Likes Silver; Trump Wants Even More Stimulus - 22nd Oct 20
Hacking Wall Street to Close the Wealth Gap - 22nd Oct 20
Natural Gas/UNG Stepping GAP Patterns Suggest Pending Upside Breakout - 22nd Oct 20 -
NVIDIA CANCELS RTX 3070 16b RTX 3080 20gb GPU's Due to GDDR6X Memory Supply Issues - 22nd Oct 20
Zafira B Leaking Water Under Car - 22nd Oct 20
The Copper/Gold Ratio Would Change the Macro - 21st Oct 20
Are We Entering Stagflation That Will Boost Gold Price - 21st Oct 20
Crude Oil Price Stalls In Resistance Zone - 21st Oct 20
High-Profile Billionaire Gives Urgent Message to Stock Investors - 21st Oct 20
What's it Like to be a Budgie - Unique in a Cage 4K VR 360 - 21st Oct 20
Auto Trading: A Beginner Guide to Automation in Forex - 21st Oct 20
Gold Price Trend Forecast into 2021, Is Intel Dying?, Can Trump Win 2020? - 20th Oct 20
Gold Asks Where Is The Inflation - 20th Oct 20
Last Chance for this FREE Online Trading Course Worth $129 value - 20th Oct 20
More Short-term Stock Market Weakness Ahead - 20th Oct 20
Dell S3220DGF 32 Inch Curved Gaming Monitor Unboxing and Stand Assembly and Range of Movement - 20th Oct 20
Best Retail POS Software In Australia - 20th Oct 20
From Recession to an Ever-Deeper One - 19th Oct 20
Wales Closes Border With England, Stranded Motorists on Severn Bridge? Covid-19 Police Road Blocks - 19th Oct 20
Commodity Bull Market Cycle Starts with Euro and Dollar Trend Changes - 19th Oct 20
Stock Market Melt-Up Triggered a Short Squeeze In The NASDAQ and a Utilities Breakout - 19th Oct 20
Silver is Like Gold on Steroids - 19th Oct 20
Countdown to Election Mediocrity: Why Gold and Silver Can Protect Your Wealth - 19th Oct 20
“Hypergrowth” Is Spilling Into the Stock Market Like Never Before - 19th Oct 20
Is Oculus Quest 2 Good Upgrade for Samsung Gear VR Users? - 19th Oct 20
Low US Dollar Risky for Gold - 17th Oct 20
US 2020 Election: Are American's ready for Trump 2nd Term Twilight Zone Presidency? - 17th Oct 20
Custom Ryzen 5950x, 5900x, 5800x , RTX 3080, 3070 64gb DDR4 Gaming PC System Build Specs - 17th Oct 20
Gold Jumps above $1,900 Again - 16th Oct 20
US Economic Recovery Is in Need of Some Rescue - 16th Oct 20
Why You Should Focus on Growth Stocks Today - 16th Oct 20
Why Now is BEST Time to Upgrade Your PC System for Years - Ryzen 5000 CPUs, Nvidia RTX 3000 GPU's - 16th Oct 20
Beware of Trump’s October (November?) Election Surprise - 15th Oct 20
Stock Market SPY Retesting Critical Resistance From Fibonacci Price Amplitude Arc - 15th Oct 20
Fed Chairman Begs Congress to Stimulate Beleaguered US Economy - 15th Oct 20
Is Gold Market Going Back Into the 1970s? - 15th Oct 20
Things you Should know before Trade Cryptos - 15th Oct 20
Gold and Silver Price Ready For Another Rally Attempt - 14th Oct 20
Do Low Interest Rates Mean Higher Stocks? Not so Fast… - 14th Oct 20
US Debt Is Going Up but Leaving GDP Behind - 14th Oct 20
Dell S3220DGF 31.5 Inch VA Gaming Monitor Amazon Prime Day Bargain Price! But WIll it Get Delivered? - 14th Oct 20
Karcher K7 Pressure Washer Amazon Prime Day Bargain 51% Discount! - 14th Oct 20
Top Strategies Day Traders Adopt - 14th Oct 20

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Get Rich Investing in Stocks by Riding the Electron Wave

NASDAQ-100 Bubble Bust Compared To S&P 500 Stocks Index

Stock-Markets / Stock Market Valuations Jan 13, 2010 - 11:06 AM GMT

By: Andrew_Butter

Stock-Markets

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleInteresting remark in a recent article by Karl Denninger:

But in 2003 credit was rapidly expanding, as it was in 2004. This is why the S&P expanded back to (and slightly beyond) its previous high - that was all financial leverage. The Nasdaq, made up of companies that made "things" (and services) for the most part, did not recover because it was not able to play financial engineering.


Now credit is contracting strongly ex-government, and even with the government's borrow-and-spend policies total outstanding credit is not expanding at any meaningful pace.

So if the S&P's recovery in the 2000s was based on financial leverage (it was) while the Nasdaq's "recovery" was what you get minus that leverage what happens to the broader indices that are polluted with the "leverage required" firms when the market figures out that the leverage is not coming back?

http://seekingalpha.com/article/181189-western-government-sovereign-debt-in-trouble

I certainly agreed with the first part of that statement which is that the mistake that the Fed made in 2001 was to create a monetary stimulus that helped those that had made bad investments in the build-up to the bubble get off the hook.  Following that logic through to it’s conclusion was how I came up (in January 2009) with a prediction for the S&P 500 turn at 675; the idea there was that the bottom in response to the peak in 2001 hadn’t come in properly, but one way or the other, someone had to take their medicine.

But come to think of it, it makes sense that “stimulus” affected the companies that make money out of leverage more than those that, as Karl correctly points out, live by making things (and services) people want to buy, and can’t make a “profit” just by hiring a smarter accountant.

I hadn’t thought of that.

In fact I never thought about the NASDAQ either, so I had a look, this is the chart I came up with:

Background:

Briefly, the Orange Line (OMV) Other-Than-Market-Value is my estimate of what the indexes should have been (left hand scale for the S&P 5-00 and right hand scale for the NASDAQ), if the market was not in what International Valuation Standards and George Soros calls “disequilibrium”.

How I got to that line is I did a valuation using International Valuation Standards.

How you do that is you pick up a copy of the Standards and follow the procedures, it’s a bit like painting by numbers, theoretically two independent valuers ought to get to the same result, although as far as I know I’m the only person who did a valuation of the stock market using IVS.

There are other ways to work out that line; Andrew Smithers uses Tobin’s “q” and Professor Shiller uses P/E ratios, both call the line “Fair Value” (nothing to do with the accountancy definition of Fair Value”). Ben Bernanke has taken to calling it  “fundamental value”, although since he claims that he doesn’t have a clue how to work out what it is (I believe him), that’s a bit academic.

The line I get using IVS is different from the line you get using Tobin’s “q” and P/E ratios. Which is right – well who knows?

Personally I like to use a recognised valuation standard whenever I do a valuation (those other methods are not in line with any recognized valuation standard that I ever heard of).

 Apart from the fact that I did use IVS, the only other evidence that I can produce to suggest my line is the “right” line, is that based on that line you can get to a logic which (a) in January predicted the turn at 675 (which happened in March) (b) said there would be a strong rally afterwards (there was), and (c) in May it predicted that the DOW would keep on going up at least until it hit 10,000 without a “serious reversal” (it did).

Anyway, that’s the line I use.

Discussion

By that calculation at the peak of the bubble in 2000 the NASDAQ was about 4x OMV and the S&P 500 was about 2x OMV

According to the Seven Immutable Laws of Bubbles that means the bottom of the trough should have come in about ¼ of OMV for the NASDAQ and ½ OMV for the S&P 500.

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article12114.html

That’s about 323 for the NASDAQ (that’s the red dot on the chart) and about 495 for the S&P 500 (that’s the blue dot on the chart).

They didn’t, the NASDAQ turned out losing 50% of what it “should” have lost (according to my calculation) if the Fed hadn’t stepped in and used taxpayer money (current and future), to save the skins of all the malinvestment  Ponzi Scheme merchants, and about 20% for the S&P 500.

S&P 500

What happened next was that the S&P 500 (according to my numbers) more or less tracked OMV until 2008, until the house of cards finally came crashing down around everyone’s heads and even the Government of the Most Powerful Nation on Earth was unable to rig the marketplace so that the malinvestments of the past didn’t start to implode, and the 50% of the peak in 2000 came in, like clockwork, exactly as the model predicted.

The moral of that story is that once malinvestments have been made, (thanks to a bubble), you can’t start again until all of those have been washed out of the system.

Funny how Allan Greenspan was happy to stand by whilst the bubble was forming, saying that the “market can look after itself”, and that he couldn’t recognize a bubble even if someone hit him over the head with a copy of International Valuation Standards, but when the whole thing exploded, well he started meddling with the market.

There are TWO things you can do wrong with Bubbles if you are a regulator:

1: Let them happen in the first place (if you know how to do a valuation it’s not hard to recognise them).

2: If you did let them happen, than panic and rush around using taxpayer money (and the money of their grandchildren), to pay off everyone who made a lousy investment and try and sweep the pain under the carpet.

Alan Greenspan made TWO mistakes, not one.

The net result was that a downturn of about seven years whilst the lunacy got “cleaned up”, just got extended to 14 years (i.e. seven years from now is how long this analysis estimates before the S&P 500 will naturally lie at OMV).

That’s why I’m saying that if the S&P 500 comes up to any more than 80% of OMV (right now that’s 80% of 1,500 = 1,250), it’s highly likely there will be a 20% or so reversal (i.e. down to about 1,000).

NASDAQ

To my way of thinking the NASDAQ looks different.

First it got in 50% of where it should have gone (rather than 25% in the case of the S&P 500), second from 2002 to 2008 it bumbled along about 10% to 20% below OMV.

So that’s seven years “on the bench” which is enough time for the malinvestments leading up to 2000 to be shaken out. So for me, it would have been no surprise that in early 2008 the NASDAQ crept up to OMV (I wasn’t actually looking at it but that’s by-the-by).

If (then) I’d been asked to take a bet on what would have happened next I would have said that the NASDAQ was in good shape; and I would have been wrong (I wasn’t asked and I didn’t take the bet).

I’m mulling that over right now. My inclination is to say that the NASDAQ got hit just because the whole market got hit, not because there was a lot of malinvestment or mispricing; like it got hammered unfairly, “in sympathy”.

If that’s right, then the NASDAQ-100 “ought” to creep up to 2,250 to 2,500 in the next year to 18 months, whilst the S&P 500 basically goes (on average) sideways.

That makes some sort of sense, as Karl Denninger was saying, companies on the NASDAQ make things and they provide services, and so they don’t rely half as much on financial tricks and leverage to produce “earnings”.

And until securitization re-starts (unlikely in 2010, and perhaps not even in 2011), anyone who relies on leverage or financial tomfoolery to hit their earnings targets, are going to be left in the dust.

By Andrew Butter

Twenty years doing market analysis and valuations for investors in the Middle East, USA, and Europe; currently writing a book about BubbleOmics. Andrew Butter is managing partner of ABMC, an investment advisory firm, based in Dubai ( hbutter@eim.ae ), that he setup in 1999, and is has been involved advising on large scale real estate investments, mainly in Dubai.

© 2010 Copyright Andrew Butter- All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

Andrew Butter Archive

© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules