Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Investing in a Bubble Mania Stock Market Trending Towards Financial Crisis 2.0 CRASH! - 9th Sep 21
2.Tech Stocks Bubble Valuations 2000 vs 2021 - 25th Sep 21
3.Stock Market FOMO Going into Crash Season - 8th Oct 21
4.Stock Market FOMO Hits September Brick Wall - Evergrande China's Lehman's Moment - 22nd Sep 21
5.Crypto Bubble BURSTS! BTC, ETH, XRP CRASH! NiceHash Seizes Funds on Account Halting ALL Withdrawals! - 19th May 21
6.How to Protect Your Self From a Stock Market CRASH / Bear Market? - 14th Oct 21
7.AI Stocks Portfolio Buying and Selling Levels Going Into Market Correction - 11th Oct 21
8.Why Silver Price Could Crash by 20%! - 5th Oct 21
9.Powell: Inflation Might Not Be Transitory, After All - 3rd Oct 21
10.Global Stock Markets Topped 60 Days Before the US Stocks Peaked - 23rd Sep 21
Last 7 days
Stock Market January PANIC AI Tech Stocks Buying Opp - Trend Forecast 2022 - 21st Jan 21
How to Get Rich in the MetaVerse - 20th Jan 21
Should you Buy Payment Disruptor Stocks in 2022? - 20th Jan 21
2022 the Year of Smart devices, Electric Vehicles, and AI Startups - 20th Jan 21
Oil Markets More Animated by Geopolitics, Supply, and Demand - 20th Jan 21
Fake It Till You Make It: Will Silver’s Motto Work on Gold? - 19th Jan 22
Crude Oil Smashing Stocks - 19th Jan 22
US Stagflation: The Global Risk of 2022 - 19th Jan 22
Stock Market Trend Forecast Early 2022 - Tech Growth Value Stocks Rotation - 18th Jan 22
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: Are We Setting Up For A 'Mini-Crash'? - 18th Jan 22
Mobile Sports Betting is on a rise: Here’s why - 18th Jan 22
Exponential AI Stocks Mega-trend - 17th Jan 22
THE NEXT BITCOIN - 17th Jan 22
Gold Price Predictions for 2022 - 17th Jan 22
How Do Debt Relief Services Work To Reduce The Amount You Owe? - 17th Jan 22
RIVIAN IPO Illustrates We are in the Mother of all Stock Market Bubbles - 16th Jan 22
All Market Eyes on Copper - 16th Jan 22
The US Dollar Had a Slip-Up, but Gold Turned a Blind Eye to It - 16th Jan 22
A Stock Market Top for the Ages - 16th Jan 22
FREETRADE - Stock Investing Platform, the Good, Bad and Ugly Review, Free Shares, Cancelled Orders - 15th Jan 22
WD 14tb My Book External Drive Unboxing, Testing and Benchmark Performance Amazon Buy Review - 15th Jan 22
Toyland Ferris Wheel Birthday Fun at Gulliver's Rother Valley UK Theme Park 2022 - 15th Jan 22
What You Should Know About a TailoredPay High Risk Merchant Account - 15th Jan 22
Best Metaverse Tech Stocks Investing for 2022 and Beyond - 14th Jan 22
Gold Price Lagging Inflation - 14th Jan 22
Get Your Startup Idea Up And Running With These 7 Tips - 14th Jan 22
What Happens When Your Flight Gets Cancelled in the UK? - 14th Jan 22
How to Profit from 2022’s Biggest Trend Reversal - 11th Jan 22
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: Are We Ready To Drop To 4400SPX? - 11th Jan 22
What's the Role of an Affiliate Marketer? - 11th Jan 22
Essential Things To Know Before You Set Up A Limited Liability Company - 11th Jan 22
Fiscal and Monetary Cliffs Have Arrived - 10th Jan 22
The Meteoric Rise of Investing in Trading Cards - 10th Jan 22
IBM The REAL Quantum Metaverse STOCK! - 9th Jan 22
WARNING Failing NVME2 M2 SSD Drives Can Prevent Systems From Booting - Corsair MP600 - 9th Jan 22
The Fed’s inflated cake and a ‘quant’ of history - 9th Jan 22
NVME M2 SSD FAILURE WARNING Signs - Corsair MP600 1tb Drive - 9th Jan 22
Meadowhall Sheffield Christmas Lights 2021 Shopping - Before the Switch on - 9th Jan 22
How Does Insurance Work In Europe? Find Out Here - 9th Jan 22
Effect of Deflation On The Gold Price - 7th Jan 22
Stock Market 2022 Requires Different Strategies For Traders/Investors - 7th Jan 22
Old Man Winter Will Stimulate Natural Gas and Heating Oil Demand - 7th Jan 22
Is The Lazy Stock Market Bull Strategy Worth Considering? - 7th Jan 22
What Elliott Waves Show for Asia Pacific Stock and Financial Markets 2022 - 6th Jan 2022
Why You Should Register Your Company - 6th Jan 2022
4 Ways to Invest in Silver for 2022 - 6th Jan 2022
UNITY (U) - Metaverse Stock Analysis Investing for 2022 and Beyond - 5th Jan 2022
Stock Market Staving Off Risk-Off - 5th Jan 2022
Gold and Silver Still Hungover After New Year’s Eve - 5th Jan 2022
S&P 500 In an Uncharted Territory, But Is Sky the Limit? - 5th Jan 2022

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How to Protect your Wealth by Investing in AI Tech Stocks

State Schools Are an Inevitable Source of Ethnic Conflict

Politics / Educating Children Sep 08, 2012 - 12:22 PM GMT



Diamond Rated - Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleMike Reid writes: The great antifascist scholar Ludwig von Mises warned that government schools are an inevitable source of ethnic conflict, because dominant nationalities can use them to indoctrinate children from other cultures, pulling them away from their parents and communities.[1] In Canada, this was explicitly the aim of the Indian residential schools, which sought to "kill the Indian in the child."[2]

The Canadian government began the schooling of aboriginal children in earnest by setting up the residential-school program in 1883. The goal was to take kids away from their disobedient, barbarian parents and make them into submissive, civilized British subjects.

By the time the last of the Indian residential schools closed its doors in 1996, they were infamous for rock-bottom standards of education and sky-high rates of physical and sexual assault against children.[3]

But the source of the brutality in residential schools was essentially the same as that of other public schools in multicultural states. Mises, an Austrian Jew, was probably thinking about the ethnic strife in his homeland when he wrote,

In those extensive areas in which peoples speaking different languages live together side by side … [t]he school can alienate children from the nationality to which their parents belong.… Whoever controls the schools has the power to injure other nationalities and to benefit his own. (Liberalism, p. 114)

In Canada, the cultural gulf between the ruling English, French, and Scottish cultures and the dozens of subjugated aboriginal cultures was exceptionally wide. Many Europeans believed it was their own destiny to dominate this wild land, and the natives' destiny to disappear or assimilate. But the natives were not going away quietly.

In 1886, one year after armed Métis and Cree uprisings in the western prairies, Indian-school inspector John McRae remarked, "It is unlikely that any Tribe or tribes would give trouble of a serious nature to the Government whose members had children completely under Government control."[4]

Come for the Food. Stay for the Shackles.

The state hired clergymen to run the schools (partly because they were cheap to hire), and as a result many former students identify their awful experiences with missionary Christianity rather than with coercive government. Certainly, many supposedly Christian teachers in the residential schools have foul crimes to answer for.

But the state appointed the principals; it built the schools; it paid for the system. Most importantly, the state corralled the children through the school doors.

The government schools were compulsory for all Indians under age 16. State agents enforced this rule only sporadically at first, but the government had other methods of persuasion.

Most aboriginal people in Canada were by the late 1800s subject to massive state regulation. The state confined them to reserves and forbade them to sell any produce to non-Indians without written permission from a government "Indian agent." Aboriginal people also could not (and in most cases still cannot) privately own any real estate on the reserves.

There is no liberty without economic liberty. Some aboriginal parents wanted their children to get a Western education. But because they were economically trapped in reserve life, such parents couldn't travel around, much less shop around for good options. They were stuck with the monopoly provider, the residential schools.

In other cases, families were simply starving because of the socialistic control of their lives. They figured that at school their children would at least be well fed.[5]

Still other parents kept their kids out of the government officials' hands however they could. One girl remembers that her father "sent me to hide in the woods. He told the Indian agent I wasn't home, which was true. I was hiding in a hollow stump."[6]

The schools themselves were often located many miles from any child's reserve, partly to save costs by operating at central locations and partly to make running away difficult. Several children died trying to make it back home through the wilderness.

When the teachers caught a runaway, they might horsewhip him in front of the other students as an example. Or the teachers might lock him in solitary confinement for days, or simply chain him to his bed at night.

One father who travelled to visit his daughter at school saw a girl with her legs shackled together to keep her from getting up enough speed to escape.


In his introduction to Separating School and State, Misesian scholar Richard Ebeling wrote of public schools in general that

The parent has been viewed — and still is viewed — as a backward and harmful influence in the formative years of the child's upbringing, an influence that must be corrected for.… The public school, therefore, is a "reeducation camp." (p. xiv)

In the residential schools, reeducation was taken to its logical extreme. The teachers believed that every aspect of an aboriginal child's upbringing was a threat to his chances of becoming a loyal British subject.

Most of the cultures these kids were being snatched from were largely anarchic, voluntary societies. There was warfare, but no conscription. There was trade, but no taxation. There were leaders, but no rulers.

There were elders to give advice, but there were no kings or presidents to give commands.[7] Each man and woman decided for himself what to do each day.

Traditionally, the whole point of a child's education in such a culture was to prepare him to make smart decisions on his own to help his family survive and grow. For Cree hunters of the boreal forests, for example, the most challenging moments in a man's economic life came when he was stalking an animal in the bush, with no one around for miles to tell him where to go or what to do next.

So these cultures' methods of education prepared kids to be radically independent. Parents almost never used corporal punishment. They taught children to handle their own emotions and make their own decisions.

No wonder the government teachers thought these people were unruly savages. They had never learned to obey.

The famous Indian Affairs bureaucrat and poet Duncan Campbell Scott worried that "without education and with neglect the Indians would produce an undesirable and often dangerous element in society."[8]

To neutralize this dangerous element, the residential-school teachers set out to destroy every symbol of a child's membership in his home culture. Teachers cut off the children's long, braided hair and confiscated their furs and beads. They dressed all their pupils in school uniforms instead.

The following before-and-after pictures of the Cree pupil "Thomas Moore" (ca. 1897) show the intended transition from threatening savage to obedient student.

Figure 1

Yes, in the "before" picture, he is carrying a revolver.[9]

The teachers also took away the names that parents had given their children, and called them by new names, ones the teachers could pronounce. (In some schools, they simply used numbers instead.) And teachers used the strap or worse on any child who spoke a word in his native tongue — often the only language he knew.

Indeed, the school staff used corporal punishment for almost every conceivable offense. One Indian agent remarked in 1896 that the teachers' violent methods "would not be tolerated in a white school for a single day in any part of Canada."[10]

But the children of savages needed to learn what it meant to obey under threat of force. They now entered a world of total control: the teachers told them, as one former pupil said,

when to go to the bathroom, when to eat, when to do this and that, when to pray. We were even told when to yawn and cough. Children can't help themselves when they cough, but we were told, "Stop your barking!"[11]

These schools were meant to irrevocably separate each child from his family's culture. One student, Charlie Bigknife,

recalled being told, after his hair had been sheared off at the File Hills school in Saskatchewan, "Now you are no longer an Indian."[12]

On top of all this, teachers — and older students who had already been warped by the schools — sexually abused many, many boys and girls. The victims' shame and confusion only compounded the psychological attack on their identities.

"This Must Never Happen Again"

Students devised elaborate means of resistance. They used sign languages to communicate with each other, staged raids on the kitchens to steal the teachers' superior food, banded together to protect themselves from abuse, tried repeatedly to escape, and sometimes even set fire to the schools.

But in the end, the residential schools were often successful in crippling their pupils' ability to function in their parents' cultures. Forbidden to speak their home languages for ten months at a time, children often found when they came home for the summer that they couldn't understand their parents or elders, nor could they explain what had happened at school. The children also hadn't learned any of the skills they needed to succeed economically or socially or even emotionally in their parents' communities.

In Canada, this is how the West was won.

For many children, the schools also failed to give them the skills that could have helped them function in the mainstream Canadian economy (even if all the regulations on Indian life had been repealed). Unsurprisingly, as a monopoly provider to an incarcerated population, the school system maintained very, very low standards of education. The abuse, the isolation, and the lack of real education left many graduates unable to be healthy members of any society.

It is fashionable now in Canada to say that the main cause of this nightmare was the racist European belief in Indian inferiority. That is a comforting thought; explicit racism has been in retreat for much of the last century.

But the real danger remains. So long as I have the power to take your children away from you for ten months of the year, teaching them what I believe and treating them how I see fit, you and your way of life can never be safe. If you have that power over my children instead, then I and my traditions can never be safe.

As Mises taught us,

In all areas of mixed nationality, the school is a political prize of the highest importance. It cannot be deprived of its political character as long as it remains a public and compulsory institution. (Liberalism, p. 115)

The Canadian government's recent Truth and Reconciliation Commission report on these horrific schools concludes, "This must never happen again."

The best way to ensure it does not is to heed the words of Mises:

There is, in fact, only one solution: the state, the government, the laws must not in any way concern themselves with schooling or education.

[1] See his discussion of dialect and standard language in Nation, State, and Economy beginning on p. 46, and his discussion of the role of government schools a couple of pages later.

[2] They Came for the Children: Canada, Aboriginal Peoples, and Residential Schools. Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. This useful report collects the testimony of many written and oral accounts from eyewitnesses of the residential schools.

[3] In Canada, many aboriginal people consider the word "Indian" a derogatory slur. It is also a legal category of persons in federal law. Thus, an insult is written into the statutes.

[4] Quoted in They Came for the Children, p. 13.

[5] In this, they were often mistaken.

[6] Quoted in They Came for the Children, p. 55.

[7] In many cases, even the institution of "chiefs" was merely a European fantasy later coded into government law.

[8] Quoted in They Came for the Children, p. 33.

[9] John Milloy drew my attention to these pictures, which he used on the cover of his shocking, erudite book A National Crime: The Canadian Government and the Residential School System, 1879 to 1986.

[10] Quoted in They Came for the Children, p. 38.

[11] Quoted in They Came for the Children, p. 24.

[12] They Came for the Children, p. 22.

Mike Reid is primus inter pares at Invisible Order, a libertarian editorial-solutions company. He also teaches anthropology at the University of Winnipeg. Send him mail. Follow him on Twitter. See Mike Reid's article archives.

You can subscribe to future articles by Mike Reid via this RSS feed.

© 2012 Copyright Ludwig von Mises - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.

© 2005-2019 - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


09 Sep 12, 11:48
Thanks for Republishing

Many thanks to the people at the Market Oracle for republishing my humble article.

Keep up the great work.

Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in